“My boss’s capacity for work is extraordinary.  But she seems to think that’s normal and expects us all to function in the same way.”

It’s easy to fall into this trap as a leader, and I’ve certainly been guilty of this in my early leadership career, not realizing my energy and capacity for work wasn’t the same for everyone.

The reality is people do have different thresholds and capacity for work and as a leader you need to be mindful of transferring your own ways of working onto others.

We aren’t talking about tolerating loafers here or allowing people to bring less than their best, we are talking about having reasonable expectations and demands on roles and incumbents.

Here’s some signs your unrealistic expectations (for yourself as well as others) may be causing problems for your team:

  1. You constantly feel like people aren’t working hard enough, or at the level you want them to.
  2. When it’s time for someone to act up in your role, there’s a lack of willing takers. (Be warned, modelling unrealistic expectations in your role is a sure-fire way to kill succession planning efforts.)
  3. Your team are exhausted, working extra hours and still feel like they’re not doing enough or meeting your expectations.
  4. There’s fear permeating and team members sniping at (and about) each other. Because if you’re not happy, they’d rather you focus on one of their peers than on them (this isn’t quite as Machiavellian as it sounds, rather normal unconscious human behaviour in the circumstances – aka survival mode).

What to do if you’re worried this is you:

Take a moment and reflect on your career, then on these questions:

  1. Have you ever been told your work pace or productivity is impressive?
  2. Have you noticed your ability to produce/complete/tolerate work is above your peers?
  3. Have you been promoted based on your ability to “get stuff done”?
  4. Do you work at your best when you’re under pressure?
  5. Do you love the feeling of completion/achieving tasks? (As in ‘the fuels you to do more/obsessive’ feeling, not just the sense of relief we all get).
  6. Have you ever had feedback from your team or those around you that your expectations may be unreasonable?
  7. Have you ever had to pull people up on performance because you feel they are not getting enough done?
  8. Do you use work as a distraction?

If you answered Yes to any of these questions it could be that your expectations are unrealistic.  Whilst setting stretch goals and targets and driving high performance is healthy and a key part of leadership, permanent unrealistic expectations are less healthy and may not be serving you, your team or the organization well.

If you want to chat about this and explore if your unrealistic /expectations may be getting in the way of your own and others success, please reach out.

Tanya Heaney-Voogt

Director & Principal Consultant
MBA, ICFACC, MAHRI, Dip Mgt, Dip Coaching, Prosci® Certified Change Practitioner
E: tanya@tanyaheaneyvoogt.com

Recent Blogs

Leaders Are Crying Out For Support

Leaders Are Crying Out For Support Only 48% of managers strongly agreeing that they currently have the skills needed to be exceptional at their jobs (Gallup). The work environment continues to shift and evolve with Leaders assuming more and more responsibility and...

What To Do If An Employee Tells You They’re “Stressed”

What To Do If An Employee Tells You They're "Stressed" I once had a frustrated leader bark at me "How am I supposed to know if my team member really is stressed or not?" It was in the middle of a workshop with 50 other leaders in the room. His frustration was...

New Data Reveals New Insights

Traditionally, data showed that people left leaders not workplaces. New data received this month shows that the most frequent reason for employees to leave their organisation is excessive workload. Sure, there's potentially a correlation if concerns aren't being...

The Real Cost of Interruptions

The Real Cost of Interruptions How long does it take to get back into the ‘zone’ after an interruption? By the “zone” I mean that sense of flow, where you are productive and totally absorbed in the task at hand.  Researchers at the University of California found it...

Navigating the Blind Spots of the ‘Empathy’ Clifton Strengths Talent

Sophie always knew she felt things more deeply than others.In meetings, she could sense tension before anyone spoke a word. When a team member was struggling, she was the first to notice. People gravitated to her when they needed someone to confide in. And as a...

Navigating the Blind Spots of the ‘Responsibility’ Clifton Strength

Victoria was the person everyone relied on at work. If a deadline was in jeopardy, she stepped in. If a team member was struggling, she picked up the slack. She prided herself on being dependable, always delivering on promises, and ensuring everything ran smoothly....

Bringing the Outside In – Using Nature in the Office to Boost Mood

There is no end of evidence that proves nature is good for our mental and physical wellbeing. What we have often felt has now been proven as fact, that sense of soul restoration, of mental clarity we get if we lose ourselves in a forest for a while for example. Or...

The Importance of Post-Incident Support for Minor OVA in the Workplace

Written By: Alexandra Heaney As a Mental Health Nurse who spent many years working in a large metropolitan public mental health facility, I have seen my fair share of OVA. It’s interesting when I reflect on some of the things that occurred in my time there, and I...

Struggling to Activate Your Psychosocial Safety Initiatives? Understand the WHY

I caught up with a legal colleague recently and we spent some time discussing how psychosocial safety initiatives still lack traction in many Australian workplaces. We mused over the fact that workplaces are change saturated, resource lean and struggling to CREATE...

Is Change Resistance Taking Up Space? How I finally embraced AI to create space

It’s 2025 and hasn’t the year has gotten off to a cracking pace? Those I was meeting with in mid-January were talking about the lack of "ease back in" time this year. Of course, in many ways we perpetuate this. It’s helpful to now and again stop and ask:  How might I...